Embryonic stem-cell policy struck down

August 24th, 2010 by Joe Towalski
SCIENCE/LIFE ISSUES/STEM CELLS

A microscopic view shows a colony of human embryonic stem cells (light blue) growing on fibroblasts (dark blue). (CNS photo / Alan Trounson, California Institute for Regenerative Medicine via Reuters)

A district court judge overturned government rules Aug. 23 set in place last year by the Obama administration that expanded federal funding for embryonic stem-cell research.

Judge Royce Lamberth of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia said the administration’s policy essentially violated Congress’ Dickey-Wicker Amendment, which bans federal funding for research that destroys human embryos.

A story in The New York Times summed up the rationale behind the ruling, which rejected a nuance that was key to the administration’s policy:

The judge ruled that the Obama Administration’s policy was illegal because the administration’s distinction between work that leads to the destruction of embryos — which cannot be funded by the federal government under present policy — and the funding of work using stem cells created through embryonic destruction is meaningless. In his ruling, he referred to embryonic stem cell research by its acronym, E.S.C.

“If one step or ‘piece of research’ of an E.S.C. research project results in the destruction of an embryo, the entire project is precluded from receiving federal funding,” wrote Judge Lamberth, who was appointed to the federal bench in 1987 by President Reagan.

In other words, the neat lines that the government had drawn between the process of embryonic destruction and the results of that destruction are not valid, the judge ruled.

Basically, the judge said, you can’t federally fund research that uses destroyed embryos and, at the same time, say those federal funds aren’t linked to the destruction of embryos.

A policy instituted by former President George W. Bush allowed federal funding of embryonic stem-cell research only on stem-cell lines that were created before Aug. 9, 2001. The Obama administration changed that policy. It allowed research using those stem-cell lines as well as lines from embryos created for reproductive purposes at in vitro fertilization clinics and no longer needed for that purpose.

The U.S. bishops have criticized the policy. In the meantime, the extent of the impact of the latest ruling is still unclear. Watch here for updates.

Will Mars look as big as full Moon next week?

August 20th, 2010 by Joe Towalski
Mars_Hubble

Mars from the Hubble Space Telescope (Photo: NASA and ESA)

Imagine looking out your window on a late August night and seeing the planet Mars hovering in the sky as large as the nearly full moon. It would be an amazing sight!

A recent e-mail forwarded to me from a work colleague promised just that: On the night of Aug. 27, it said, Mars will be at its brightest and “it will look like the earth has 2 moons.”

The next time Mars comes this close, it added, will be in the year 2287. “Share this with your friends as NO ONE ALIVE TODAY will ever see it again.”

Sounds impressive. The only problem? It’s not true.

It seems this myth started in 2003 when Mars reached a point called opposition, when it is closest to the Earth and appears larger and brighter than any other time of the year.

Opposition this year, however, happened last January. And, in any case, a bigger and brighter Mars doesn’t mean the planet appears Moon-size (although it did appear bigger and brighter in 2003 than it will until 2287)

The editors at Astronomy magazine summed it up nicely when they recently addressed the myth: “For Mars to look that large, it somehow would have to jump out of its orbit and move some 34 million miles (55 million kilometers) closer to the Sun.”

The magazine also did a great job explaining how the myth began.

Even though Mars won’t look gigantic in the night sky, it’s still pretty fun to see, whether you’re viewing it through a telescope, binoculars or with your naked eye. Look for it in the evening sky in the west.

Good news on stem-cell front

August 18th, 2010 by Joe Towalski

microscopeThe Minneapolis StarTribune recently published a story detailing how University of Minnesota doctors are using bone marrow transplants for an experimental treatment to improve the lives of children suffering from a devastating genetic skin disease — signaling what could be an important advance in the use of adult stem cells.

A week earlier, the same newspaper carried a story about how adult stem cells — those found in adult human tissue and blood, not embryos — are being used for a variety of therapies and potential life-saving research.

The story pointed out:

“Adult stem cells are being studied in people who suffer from multiple sclerosis, heart attacks and diabetes. Some early results suggest stem cells can help some patients avoid leg amputation. Recently, researchers reported that they restored vision to patients whose eyes were damaged by chemicals.

“Apart from these efforts, transplants of adult stem cells have become a standard lifesaving therapy for perhaps hundreds of thousands of people with leukemia, lymphoma and other blood diseases.”

In principle, this is all good news to which the church gives its blessing.

If you’re surprised by that statement, you’ve been listening too much to those who would like to convince you (wrongly) that the church is hostile to science.

The church is fully supportive of adult stem-cell research. Earlier this year, I wrote about how foundations affiliated with an international biopharmaceutical company and the Pontifical Council for Culture planned to work together to educate people around the world about the benefits of adult stem-cell research to treat disease and alleviate suffering.

The church, however, opposes embryonic stem-cell research because it requires the destruction of a living human embryo in order to harvest the cells.

Does that mean the church is ultimately more concerned about protecting clumps of cells than helping people who suffer from terrible diseases?

Absolutely not.

The embryo is more than just a clump of cells — it is nascent human life. Anyone who tries to argue otherwise is blind to the facts of Biology 101. And religion, at its best, is about protecting and nurturing human life — no matter its age, ability or perceived usefulness to others. When human life and dignity are threatened, the church must speak up.

Think of it this way: Advancements in nuclear science — understanding  atoms and how they work — have led to some wonderful medical and health-related advancements, including cancer treatments.

But nuclear science has also led to the development of nuclear weapons, and people of faith (and no faith) have been working for decades to stop their production and use because they pose a dangerous threat to human life.

Does working for an end to nuclear weapons and weapons-related research make one an opponent of nuclear science? Obviously not. Religion and ethics help us determine the moral parameters in which science ought to operate for the benefit of humankind.

Some may object to this comparison, noting that the goal of nuclear weapons is to destroy human life while the goal of embryonic stem-cell research is ostensibly to help others.

But embryonic stem-cell research involves the destruction of human life as an integral step on the way to an otherwise noble goal, and that is where the moral problem lies.

The end can’t justify the means: You can’t intentionally destroy human life in order to benefit others. Justifying the taking of a human life in one of its earliest stages for a perceived benefit is the first step down a slippery moral slope.

That’s why advancements in adult stem-cell research are such welcome news. They’re leading to medical treatments — some proven, others promising — that don’t raise the same moral red-alert, and that’s something we can all support.

Tonight: A heavenly light show you shouldn’t miss

August 12th, 2010 by Joe Towalski

shootingstarSummer is a good time for picnics — opening a basket of snacks, stretching out on a blanket and staring up at a beautiful blue sky.

But have you ever considered having a picnic at night, say around midnight or 1 a.m., when the night sky is studded with the light of countless stars?

If that sounds intriguing, you should head to an open, grassy area late tonight (Aug. 12) or in the predawn hours on Friday, and get ready for a special light show. If the sky is clear, you’ll see not only stars and planets, but also one of the best meteor showers of the year — the Perseids.

Last year at this time, as part of the International Year of Astronomy, I wrote an editorial in The Catholic Spirit encouraging people to view this annual August display of “shooting stars” — actually small bits of rock and dust that stream brightly through the earth’s atmosphere.

This debris is associated with comet Swift-Tuttle, which orbits the sun every 133 years. As the small pieces crash toward earth, they burn up and create streaks of light across the sky. They appear to originate in the constellation Perseus, which rises in the northeast.

Last year, from my home in suburban St. Paul, I was able to see a meteor every minute or two. This year, the experts predict the shower will reach a peak of about 80 meteors per hour. The moon will set before the best part of the show kicks in, so viewing conditions should be excellent, if the weather cooperates.

The Perseids are sure to elicit oohs and aahs, especially from children and adults who’ve never seen or paid much attention to such celestial events. And, what kid doesn’t appreciate the opportunity to stay up late to see something cool?

Parents: Don’t overlook the opportunity to use this as a segue into a discussion about the awesomeness of the universe that God created and our place in it. If you’re looking for some Scripture passages to start the discussion, try these: Genesis 1:16-19, Psalm 148:1-6 and Psalm 8:1, 3-5.

If you want to learn more about the Perseids, you can join an online chat with astronomer Bill Cooke from NASA’s Marshall Space Flight Center today (Aug. 12) from 2-3 p.m. central time. He’ll answer questions about the meteor shower and the best ways to view it.

You can also visit the Hayden Planetarium’s website for additional observing tips.

So, pack a snack and a comfortable chair or blanket and head outside tonight for an awesome, heavenly light show.

Hot weather? Blame it on the dog

August 10th, 2010 by Joe Towalski
sirius

A Hubble Space Telescope image of Sirius A and its very tiny companion, Sirius B. (Photo: NASA, ESA)

The dog days of summer are definitely in full force here in Minnesota, with temperatures in the 90s expected for most of this week.

We associate the phrase “dog days” with the hottest part of the summer — days marked by pool parties, parish festivals and lazy, leisurely weekends.

But did you ever wonder where the phrase “dog days” originated?

It’s connected to the star Sirius — located in the constellation Canis Major (the “Big Dog”) and nicknamed the Dog Star.

Sirius is normally the brightest star in the night sky. But in July to about mid-August, it rises with the sun. The ancients believed (wrongly, of course) that the extra heat generated by this bright star added to the sun’s output, leading to hotter summer days.

So if anyone complains to you about the heat this week, tell them to blame it on the dog.

That’s one cool telescope

August 8th, 2010 by Joe Towalski
AftonScope

Taking a look at the sun at the Joseph J. Casby Memorial Observatory. (Photo by Dianne Towalski)

As my 11-year-old son peered into the eyepiece of a new 10-inch refracting telescope recently installed in Afton, Minn., he could hardly contain his excitement. “Wow, cool!” he said looking back at me before taking another peek.

What he saw on this Saturday afternoon was the sun — its large disk dotted with three sets of sunspots — cooler areas about the size of the earth on the sun’s huge surface that you wouldn’t be able to see without the aid of a telescope and a special filter making it safe to view.

I took my turn, and then we went to the back of the line so we could wait for another peek. I can only imagine how brilliant the night sky — the moon, planets and some deeper sky objects — will look through the eyepiece.

This is one of the things I love about science: Like faith, it can elicit awe and wonder. It reminds you about the beauty, complexity and vastness of God’s creation.

We were visiting Aug. 7 during an open house unveiling the Joseph J. Casby Memorial Observatory to the public. Housed inside its own viewing dome, the $70,000 addition is one of the best amateur scopes you’re likely to see.

The telescope recently received some good press in both the Minneapolis and St. Paul daily newspapers. The observatory is a joint project of the Minnesota Astronomical Society and the Belwin Conservancy, a non-profit organization dedicated to protecting and preserving the local St. Croix Valley.

A Belwin education center, located near the observatory, is already used by some public school students, and there are reportedly plans to equip the classroom with the ability to show images from the telescope on large screens — not a bad option when Minnesota’s weather turns bitter cold.

According to the Minnesota Astronomical Society website, access to the observatory site is typically limited to MAS members and their guests. But, for anyone interested in stargazing opportunities or learning more about astronomy, MAS operates four other observing sites around the Twin Cities that often host public events. Check the MAS website for more info about the group’s “star parties.”

Addressing Galileo, again

July 30th, 2010 by Joe Towalski
VATICAN -ASTRONOMY

CNS photo/Marco Bucco, Reuters

One of my favorite Catholic blogs is “The Word on Fire,” created by Father Robert Barron. In one of the latest posts, Robert Mixa, a WOF research assistant, responds to a recent article in The New York Times that illustrates the often-misunderstood relationship between faith and science.

Mixa’s post is a good rebuttal and a good summary about what the church really teaches.

Dead Sea Scrolls mystery solved?

July 26th, 2010 by Joe Towalski
scrolls

A scroll fragment from the Book of Psalms on display at the Science Museum of Minnesota. (Photo by Dave Hrbacek / The Catholic Spirit)

The Dead Sea Scrolls exhibit at the Science Museum of Minnesota has been one of the hottest tickets in town. One aspect of the exhibit touted by organizers is that it allows visitors to draw their own conclusions about a few lingering mysteries: Who wrote the scrolls? And, where were they written?

Many scholars have concluded the scrolls were authored by members of the Qumran community near the Dead Sea caves where the 2,000-year-old texts were discovered. Others believe they were written elsewhere and hidden in the caves by Jews fleeing Jerusalem prior to the Romans destroying the Temple in A.D. 70.

A group of researchers in Italy recently weighed in on the controversy, revealing that high-tech analysis of a sample of the 28-foot-long Temple Scroll shows that the animal skin on which it is written likely originated in the Qumran area.

The researchers used a technique called “X-ray and particle-induced X-ray emission” and a particle accelerator to analyze small fragments of the scroll.

“Basically, we concentrated on water. Like most of the other parchments, the Temple Scroll was made from animal skin, thus its production required extensive washing. Our goal was to compare and possibly find a match between the chemistry of the scroll and the very peculiar chemistry of the water from the area where the parchments were found,” physicist Giuseppe Pappalardo told Discovery News.

X-rays emitted by the scroll samples showed they contained chlorine, and that the ratio of chlorine to bromine was about three times higher than normally found in seawater, the story noted. The scientists concluded the scroll could have been made using the very salty Dead Sea water.

The study, while insightful, isn’t definitive: The researchers’ theory will need to be tested further. And, if they are correct, it still only proves that the parchment likely originated near the Dead Sea; the actual writing could have been done elsewhere. The ink will also need to be analyzed.

The researchers’ findings are something to ponder while you look at the Old Testament and non-biblical fragments on display in St. Paul. The exhibit runs through Oct. 24 and includes an overview of other scientific analyses the scrolls have undergone since their discovery, including carbon-14 dating.

For more information about the exhibit, call (651) 221-9444 or visit the museum’s website.

Pollution may halt Jordan River baptisms

July 23rd, 2010 by Joe Towalski
JORDAN-BIBLICAL SITE

A visitor dips his hand into the water of the Jordan River — where it is said St. John baptized Jesus — about 30 miles west of Amman, Jordan. (CNS photo / Greg Tarczynski)

Jesus waded into the Jordan River to be baptized. But an environmental group is warning tourists and pilgrims not to follow in his footsteps.

Friends of the Earth Middle East called on local authorities this week to close a baptism site on the lower Jordan River until its polluted waters can be cleaned up.

“Sadly, the lower Jordan River has long suffered from severe mismanagement with the diversion of 98 percent of its fresh water by Israel, Syria and Jordan and the discharge of untreated sewage, agricultural run-off, saline water and fish pond effluent in its place,” the statement said, according to Discovery News.

The Israeli health ministry has not made a decision yet about whether to continue to allow people to enter the water at the site, located near the West Bank city of Jericho, added a report in Israel’s Haaretz newspaper.

Some believe the site is where Jesus was baptized by John the Baptist, although Jordan claims a rival location on the river’s east bank as the true site. The Vatican, for its part, has always downplayed such competition, noting that John baptized people throughout the river valley, not just in one place.

Last May, FoEME issued a study warning that the river has lost more than 50 percent of its biodiversity and could go dry by the end of 2011 if no action is taken. The study highlighted the need for regional authorities to develop plans to return fresh water to the river, which holds special significance for Christians, Jews and Muslims.

Put the video games away and head outdoors

July 5th, 2010 by Joe Towalski
purple1

Wild bergamot

A few years ago, I read an article about how today’s children aren’t getting outside enough. It surmised that hectic family schedules and video games were contributing to the problem. It also pointed out that in the days before computer and video screens dominated kids’ free time, obesity and diabetes weren’t as prevalent among youth as they are today.

A coincidence? Maybe. But it’s certainly true that spending time in the outdoors has a lot benefits — including spiritual ones. I’m not talking about trips to the playground or sporting events — which certainly are beneficial, too — but rather spending some carefree time in the outdoors to explore and learn more about the world God created.

In that spirit, my wife and I have started taking our 11-year-old son on evening nature walks around our neighborhood. We’re lucky to live in a place near St. Paul with a number of walking trails that wind through marshland and other undeveloped areas.

I dug out some old bird and wildflower field guides, and we hit the trails seeking to identify the plants and animals we saw along the way. My son — an admitted video game lover — had a great time trying to match up what we saw with the pictures and drawings in our guidebooks.

On one evening walk, we saw cardinals, black-capped chickadees, American goldfinches, red-winged blackbirds, prairie sunflowers, wild bergamot and Sullivant’s milkweed to name just a smatter of the flora and fauna along our route. We also heard what sounded like thousands of frogs singing together along the shore of a small pond.

If you live in an urban area, you might try a walk through the local park. If you can travel, spend a day at a state park or wildlife refuge. For ideas on places to visit in Minnesota, go to ExploreMinnesota.com. And, if you want to read more about the outdoors from a faith perspective, visit my Catholic Spirit colleague Dave Hrbacek’s blog, Faith Outdoors.

Summer is a great season to spend time outside, have fun and learn more about our natural world. Don’t miss the opportunity.